top of page

Case Study: The Business Owner Paying Taxes on Money They Had Not Collected

Writer: Noelle Heddle
Noelle Heddle
Nov 10
5 min read

A business owner came to us after receiving an unexpectedly large tax bill.


The company had reported a strong year. Revenue had increased, new contracts had been signed, and the financial statements showed substantial taxable income.


The problem was that much of the reported income had not actually been collected.


Several customers were slow to pay. Some invoices were more than 90 days old. Others were being disputed. A few customers were unlikely to pay at all.


The owner was understandably frustrated.


“How can I owe tax on money I never received?”


The answer was tied to the company's accounting method.


Cash Basis Versus Accrual Basis


Under the cash method of accounting, income is generally recognized when payment is received, and expenses are generally deducted when paid.


Under the accrual method, income is generally recognized when it is earned, even if payment has not yet been received. Expenses are generally recognized when they are incurred, even if they have not yet been paid.


Neither method is automatically better in every situation.


The appropriate method depends on the type of business, tax rules, inventory, financial reporting needs, and the company's specific circumstances.


This company was using the accrual method.


When customer invoices were issued for completed work, the revenue was recorded.


That revenue increased both accounts receivable and taxable income, even though the customers had not yet paid.


What We Found


The company's accounts receivable balance had grown significantly over the year.


Revenue was increasing, but collections were slowing.


The business was paying employees, subcontractors, vendors, and overhead expenses to complete the work. However, customer payments were arriving much later.


This created two separate problems.


First, the company had a cash-flow shortage because it had already paid many of the costs associated with the work.


Second, the company was potentially paying income tax on revenue that had been earned and recorded but not yet collected.


Aging receivables were not being reviewed


The owner knew certain customers owed money but did not have a clear report showing how long each balance had been outstanding.


Once the accounts receivable aging report was reviewed, it became clear that a substantial portion of the balance was more than 60 or 90 days old.


Collection procedures were inconsistent


Invoices were sent promptly, but there was no formal follow-up schedule.


Some customers received reminders. Others did not.


There were no standard procedures for deposits, progress billing, late fees, payment plans, or pausing additional work when an account became seriously delinquent.


Uncollectible balances had not been identified


Some invoices were unlikely to be collected due to customer disputes, business closures, insolvency, or other circumstances.


However, those balances continued to remain on the books as active receivables.


Revenue recognition was not being reviewed carefully


Certain invoices had been recorded before all work was complete or before the company had fully earned the revenue.


In other situations, customer deposits had been recorded as income even though the related work had not yet been performed.


These classifications affected the timing of income.


The owner was relying on the bank balance instead of the balance sheet


The owner primarily reviewed the checking account and profit and loss statement.


The balance sheet, including accounts receivable, customer deposits, and liabilities, received very little attention.


As a result, the owner could see the reported profit but could not easily identify how much of that profit remained uncollected.


What We Changed


We began by reconciling the accounts receivable records to the accounting system.


Each outstanding customer balance was reviewed and categorized based on age, payment status, documentation, and likelihood of collection.


The company then established a more consistent billing and collection process.


That process included:


  • Clear payment terms on invoices

  • Customer deposits when appropriate

  • Progress billing for longer projects

  • Scheduled reminders for overdue balances

  • Escalation procedures for seriously delinquent accounts

  • Documentation of disputes

  • Payment plans when reasonable

  • Review before performing additional work for delinquent customers


We also reviewed whether outstanding balances met the requirements to be treated as bad debts.


For accrual-basis taxpayers, a business bad-debt deduction may be available when an amount was previously included in income and later becomes wholly or partially worthless.


However, an invoice generally cannot be written off merely because it is late. The facts should support that the debt is genuinely uncollectible, and the business should maintain documentation of collection efforts and relevant circumstances.


Customer deposits, unearned revenue, and incomplete work were also reviewed to determine whether income had been recognized in the proper period.


Finally, tax projections were updated using more accurate year-end information so the owner could evaluate the likely tax liability before the return was completed.


Could the Business Switch to the Cash Method?


The owner asked whether switching to the cash method would solve the problem.


In some cases, an eligible business may be able to change accounting methods.


However, the decision should not be made solely to defer tax on accounts receivable.


A method change can affect:


  • The timing of income

  • The timing of deductions

  • Inventory treatment

  • Existing receivables and payables

  • Financial statement reporting

  • Loan covenants

  • Future tax years

  • Required tax filings and adjustments


Changing accounting methods may also require IRS procedures and a cumulative adjustment to prevent income or expenses from being omitted or counted twice.


The company therefore needed a broader analysis before making a change.


The Result


The immediate tax liability did not disappear simply because the invoices remained unpaid.


However, the owner gained a much clearer understanding of why taxable income and cash received were different.


Uncollectible balances were documented and addressed appropriately.


Invoices that had been recorded incorrectly were corrected.


The company strengthened its deposit, billing, and collection policies.


Management began reviewing the accounts receivable aging report regularly rather than waiting until year-end.


Tax projections also improved because they incorporated the company's accounting method, receivable balances, bad-debt exposure, and collection trends.


The Lesson


A sale is not always the same as a collection.


For an accrual-basis business, taxable income may be recognized before the customer pays. This makes accounts receivable management both an operational issue and a tax-planning issue.


Business owners should know:


  • Which accounting method they use

  • When income is recognized

  • How much customers currently owe

  • How long invoices have been outstanding

  • Which balances may be uncollectible

  • Whether deposits and incomplete work are classified correctly

  • How unpaid invoices may affect taxes and cash flow


Accurate accounting cannot force a customer to pay, but it can help a business identify collection problems sooner, report income properly, and plan for the tax consequences.


At Alliance Financial Solutions, we help business owners understand not only how much profit they earned, but also when that profit becomes cash.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page